Site icon Real Estate Law Journal

Maintenance Charges Cannot Be Collected Before Possession

Maintenance
The Haryana Real Estate Regulatory Authority (HRERA) has directed Vatika One On One and Vatika Ltd to refund escalation and maintenance charges collected from two commercial property buyers, along with 11% annual interest. The authority has also directed the developers to pay ₹2.5 lakh in compensation and litigation costs for failing to execute the conveyance deed and for the other grievances established by the buyers.

In an order dated October 16, 2026, Adjudicating Officer Rajender Kumar ruled on a complaint filed by Apurv Sharma and Anant Sharma concerning a commercial unit in the Vatika One On One project, Sector 16, Gurugram.

The order addresses the developer’s obligation to execute conveyance deeds under the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016, and the legality of collecting escalation and maintenance charges without contractual or possession-related justification.

Buyers Paid ₹43 Lakh for Commercial Unit

The complainants booked a 500-square-foot commercial unit in the project in March 2016 and paid the entire advance amount of ₹43 lakh. The buyer’s agreement was executed in May 2016.

According to the buyers, the developer initially paid assured monthly returns from April 2016 to August 2018, but subsequently stopped making the payments.

In an earlier order dated November 21, 2025, HRERA had directed the developer to pay assured returns at the rate of ₹151.60 per square foot per month until the occupation certificate was issued on September 6, 2021.

Thereafter, the rate was fixed at ₹130 per square foot per month, payable for up to three years or until the unit was leased, whichever occurred earlier.

The earlier order also required the developer to execute the conveyance deed within three months of making the final offer of possession. However, despite the buyers having paid the applicable stamp duty, the conveyance deed remained unexecuted.

Failure to Execute Conveyance Deed Violates RERA Obligations

The adjudicating officer noted that the occupation certificate had been issued for the project and examined the developer’s obligation under Section 17(1) of the RERA Act.

The provision requires the promoter to execute a registered conveyance deed in favour of the allottee within the prescribed period. The officer observed that the conveyance deed was required to be executed within three months from the issuance of the occupation certificate.

The authority held that failure to comply with this statutory obligation attracts liability under Section 18(3) of the RERA Act.

For the delay in executing the conveyance deed, HRERA awarded the buyers ₹1 lakh as compensation on a notional basis.

The authority also granted liberty to the buyers to approach it again if the conveyance deed remained unexecuted even after three months from the date of the latest order.

Vatika Directed to Refund Escalation Charges

The buyers had challenged the developer’s demand and collection of escalation charges at ₹1,080 per square foot.

They argued that the buyer’s agreement did not contain any provision authorising the developer to impose these charges.

The authority accepted the buyers’ objection and directed Vatika to refund the escalation charges collected, together with 11% annual interest from the respective dates of collection.

The direction reinforces the importance of the contractual terms governing payments between developers and allottees. A developer cannot impose additional charges without an appropriate basis in the agreement or applicable legal provisions.

Maintenance Charges Cannot Be Collected Before Possession

The complainants also disputed the maintenance charges collected by the developer before handing over possession of the commercial unit.

HRERA accepted this objection and held that maintenance charges cannot be collected before physical or notional possession is handed over.

The officer observed that since the commercial unit was intended to be leased on behalf of the buyers, the date of lease could be treated as the date of notional possession.

Accordingly, Vatika was directed to refund the maintenance charges collected before the relevant possession date, along with 11% annual interest from the respective dates of collection.

₹2.5 Lakh Awarded Towards Compensation and Litigation Costs

Apart from the refund of escalation and maintenance charges, HRERA granted the buyers the following reliefs:

  • ₹1 lakh as compensation for delay in executing the conveyance deed.

  • ₹1 lakh for mental agony.

  • ₹50,000 towards litigation costs.

The total compensation and litigation costs awarded amounted to ₹2.5 lakh.

The buyers had sought ₹10 lakh for mental agony and ₹3.20 lakh towards litigation expenses. However, the authority awarded lower amounts.

Their other claims were also partly rejected. The authority declined to grant 6% compensation on the amount paid, which the buyers had sought on the basis of an appellate tribunal order that was not placed on record. The claim for ₹35,000 towards travel expenses was also rejected.

The authority directed that all compensation and other awarded amounts would carry 11% annual interest from the date of the order.

Key Takeaway: Developers Cannot Withhold Conveyance or Collect Unjustified Charges

The HRERA ruling highlights important obligations of developers towards commercial property buyers. Under the RERA framework, promoters are required to complete the conveyance process within the prescribed period and cannot indefinitely delay the transfer of ownership documentation.

The order also reinforces that escalation charges must have a contractual basis and that maintenance charges cannot be collected before physical or notional possession is established.

For commercial property buyers, the decision underlines the importance of examining the buyer’s agreement, verifying the possession status and checking the basis of charges demanded by developers. Where conveyance deeds remain pending or charges are collected prematurely, buyers may seek appropriate relief under the RERA Act.

Exit mobile version