Site icon Real Estate Law Journal

Supreme Court Allows Sale of Flats on Disputed Property

Supreme Court
The Supreme Court has permitted a property developer to create third-party rights in flats constructed on disputed property, despite pending civil suits concerning the title to the land. However, the Court clarified that any sale or transfer of the flats would remain subject to the final outcome of the pending litigation.

A Division Bench comprising Justice B.V. Nagarathna and Justice R. Mahadevan set aside the restriction imposed by the Calcutta High Court, which had restrained the appellant from creating third-party interests or transferring the disputed property without obtaining permission from the competent civil court.

The Supreme Court also directed the appellant to specifically disclose the pendency of the litigation in the sale agreements or sale deeds executed in favour of prospective purchasers. Further, it requested the trial court to dispose of the pending suits expeditiously.

Background of the Case

The appellant approached the Supreme Court challenging the direction contained in paragraph 14 of the Calcutta High Court’s order dated August 3, 2023.

The High Court had permitted the appellant to continue construction on the disputed property in accordance with the previously sanctioned building plan. However, it restrained the appellant, his agents, partners and persons acting on his behalf from using the property, creating any third-party interest or transferring the property without obtaining leave of the competent civil court.

Challenging this restriction, the appellant submitted that the construction had already been completed and the flats were ready for sale.

The appellant argued that Section 52 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882, which incorporates the doctrine of lis pendens, permits the transfer of disputed property during the pendency of litigation, provided that such transfer remains subject to the final outcome of the proceedings.

It was further submitted that civil suits instituted by the appellant and Respondents 5 and 6 were pending and had been clubbed together. According to the appellant, the proceedings had been progressing at an extremely slow pace, with Respondents 5 and 6 allegedly seeking repeated adjournments.

Opposing the appeal, the respondents contended that the existence of a dispute concerning the title to the property prevented the appellant from creating third-party interests in the flats constructed on the disputed land.

Issue for Determination

Whether a property developer can be restrained from creating third-party interests in flats constructed on disputed property merely because competing title suits are pending before a civil court?

Supreme Court’s Analysis and Decision

The Supreme Court considered the fact that the appellant had already completed construction on the disputed property and that prospective purchasers were ready and willing to purchase the flats, subject to the outcome of the pending suits and the risks involved.

Taking these circumstances into consideration, the Court set aside paragraph 14 of the Calcutta High Court’s order dated August 3, 2023, which had restrained the appellant from creating third-party interests or transferring the property without obtaining prior permission from the competent civil court.

The Court permitted the appellant to create third-party rights in the constructed flats, notwithstanding the pendency of the title disputes.

However, the Supreme Court imposed an important condition to protect the interests of prospective purchasers.

It clarified that any sale, transfer or creation of third-party rights would remain subject to the outcome of the suits filed by the appellant and Respondents 5 and 6.

Thus, purchasers acquiring flats in the disputed property would be bound by the final decision in the pending litigation.

Disclosure of Pending Litigation Mandatory in Sale Documents

An important aspect of the Supreme Court’s decision is the requirement of transparency towards prospective purchasers.

The Court directed the appellant to disclose the pendency of the litigation between the parties in the sale agreement or sale deed executed in favour of third-party purchasers.

This direction ensures that prospective buyers are made aware of the existing title dispute before entering into a transaction.

Consequently, buyers will have an opportunity to understand the legal risks associated with purchasing flats constructed on disputed property and make an informed decision before proceeding with the transaction.

The direction also reinforces the importance of disclosure in property transactions, particularly where ownership rights are subject to adjudication before a civil court.

Trial Court Directed to Dispose of Suits Expeditiously

The Supreme Court also took note of the fact that the civil suits had been pending since 2022.

Considering the delay in the proceedings, the Court requested the trial court concerned to dispose of the pending suits as expeditiously as possible, obviously with the cooperation of the parties.

The direction seeks to ensure that the underlying title dispute is resolved without further unnecessary delay, particularly since third-party purchasers may acquire interests in the property during the pendency of the proceedings.

Significance of the Judgment for Property Developers and Homebuyers

The Supreme Court’s decision highlights an important distinction between the transferability of disputed property and the final determination of ownership rights.

The mere pendency of a civil suit concerning title does not, by itself, necessarily prohibit every transfer of the disputed property. The doctrine of lis pendens under Section 52 of the Transfer of Property Act recognises that a transfer during litigation remains subject to the rights ultimately determined by the court.

For property developers, the decision provides relief where construction has been completed but sales are restricted solely because of pending title litigation, subject to the applicable legal and judicial restrictions.

For prospective homebuyers, however, the judgment highlights the importance of conducting proper title due diligence and carefully examining disclosures in sale agreements and conveyance documents.

Purchasers must understand that acquiring a flat during pending litigation does not eliminate the underlying title dispute. Their rights may remain subject to the final decree or order passed by the competent court.

The judgment therefore balances the ability to transact in disputed property with the need to protect purchasers through mandatory disclosure and the principle that any transfer remains subject to the outcome of pending proceedings.

Key Takeaway

The Supreme Court has clarified that flats constructed on disputed property may be sold during the pendency of title suits, subject to the outcome of those proceedings. While developers may create third-party rights, they must clearly disclose the pending litigation in the relevant sale documents.

The ruling underscores the importance of Section 52 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882, the doctrine of lis pendens, transparency in property transactions and protection of prospective homebuyers.

Exit mobile version