In an order dated November 13, 2026, Adjudicating Officer Rajender Kumar held that the promoter had acted in contravention of Section 13(1) of the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016, which prohibits a promoter from accepting more than 10% of the cost of an apartment, plot or building without first entering into a written and registered agreement for sale.
The complaint was filed by Kuldeep Kumar Kohli, who purchased a ground-floor unit in Emaar’s Emerald Floors project at Emerald Hills, Sector 65, Gurugram. Kohli had sought compensation exceeding ₹50 lakh, alleging delayed possession, seepage, financial losses and other deficiencies.
Buyer Paid ₹22.6 Lakh Before Signing Builder-Buyer Agreement
Kohli booked the unit in June 2009 for a total sale consideration of ₹75.4 lakh. He paid approximately ₹22.6 lakh before the builder-buyer agreement was executed.
However, the BBA for the unit was signed only on May 28, 2010.
The possession was originally due on August 24, 2012, but Emaar offered possession in 2017 and handed over the unit in 2018.
Kohli alleged that the flat suffered from severe seepage and flooding and remained uninhabitable until March 2020. According to him, these conditions forced him to continue living in rented accommodation.
Buyer Sought Over ₹50 Lakh in Compensation
Kohli sought several amounts from the developer, including:
-
₹5 lakh for mental agony and harassment.
-
₹3 lakh towards litigation costs.
-
₹44 lakh as pecuniary damages, including rental expenses.
He also sought relief in relation to the excess amount collected before execution of the BBA and the additional stamp duty paid on registration of the conveyance deed.
Emaar Contests Complaint, Cites Limitation and Earlier Compensation
Emaar contested the complaint, arguing that it was barred by limitation. The developer submitted that Kohli had enjoyed the unit without protest after execution of the conveyance deed in August 2018.
Emaar also contended that it had already credited ₹21.6 lakh as compensation for delayed possession. It relied on an indemnity-cum-undertaking signed by the buyer in 2014.
An Emaar spokesperson stated that the company was reviewing the HRERA order and intended to challenge it before the Haryana Real Estate Appellate Tribunal (HREAT).
The spokesperson maintained that the occupation certificate for the unit had been obtained in June 2016, followed by possession and execution of the conveyance deed in 2018. The company also argued that the order overlooked important factual and legal aspects, including the non-applicability of retrospective statutory provisions to an agreement executed in 2010, before the enactment of RERA.
Emaar further stated that an earlier appeal concerning the same unit was already pending before HREAT and that it would pursue appropriate legal remedies.
No Additional Compensation for Delay in Possession
While examining the complaint, the adjudicating officer accepted the principle that an allottee who continues to remain in a project and accepts possession is not entitled to compensation beyond the interest payable for delayed possession.
Relying on decisions of the Uttar Pradesh and Haryana Real Estate Appellate Tribunals, the officer observed that an allottee who stays in the project cannot claim separate compensation for the same cause of action after receiving delayed-possession interest.
Since HRERA had already granted delay compensation in an earlier complaint decided in May 2022, the officer held that delay alone could not form the basis of a fresh compensation claim.
However, the officer separately examined Kohli’s other allegations, including the collection of more than 10% of the sale consideration before execution of the BBA.
Collecting More Than 10% Before BBA Violates Section 13(1)
A significant aspect of the order concerned Section 13(1) of the RERA Act.
The provision requires a promoter to execute and register a written agreement for sale with the allottee before accepting more than 10% of the cost of the apartment, plot or building as an advance or application fee.
In this case, Kohli had paid approximately ₹22.6 lakh against a total sale consideration of ₹75.4 lakh before the BBA was executed on May 28, 2010.
The adjudicating officer held that collecting an amount exceeding the statutory 10% threshold before execution of the agreement was contrary to the legal requirement.
On this count, the officer awarded ₹1 lakh in compensation, described as tentative interest on the excess amount collected. The officer, however, rejected the buyer’s claim for ₹4.5 lakh towards rent for nine months.
Excess Stamp Duty to Be Refunded with 11% Interest
The authority also directed Emaar to refund the excess stamp duty paid by Kohli while registering the conveyance deed.
The buyer had claimed that the excess stamp duty amounted to ₹72,300. The developer was directed to refund the amount with 11% annual interest from the date it was collected.
The reliefs granted under the order therefore include compensation for the violation relating to collection before execution of the BBA and refund of excess stamp duty with interest.
Key Takeaway: Promoters Must Execute BBA Before Collecting More Than 10%
The HRERA order highlights the importance of complying with Section 13(1) of the RERA Act, which restricts promoters from collecting more than 10% of the sale price before executing and registering an agreement for sale.
The decision also distinguishes between claims arising from delayed possession and independent statutory violations. While the adjudicating officer declined to award additional compensation for delay after earlier delay compensation had been granted, the issue of collecting more than the permitted amount before execution of the BBA was examined separately.
The order is also significant because Emaar has indicated its intention to challenge the decision before HREAT, raising questions concerning the application of RERA provisions to an agreement executed before the Act came into force.
